The real cost of a bad hire and an empty seat
Updated: Nov 4
Most businesses know what a recruitment fee costs.
Far fewer know the cost of a bad hire. Or what it costs to leave a seat empty for three months while you wait for the right person.
Both numbers are usually much bigger.

The figure nobody budgets for
Most businesses can tell you what it costs to make a hire.
Far fewer track what happens when it goes wrong.
When it is measured, the numbers are sobering. One recent survey of UK business leaders put the cost of a mis-hire at around £125,000 for a typical business.
It’s also getting harder to spot the wrong person early. More than half of employers have seen an increase in unsuitable applications over the past year and over a quarter say candidates are leaning heavily on AI to write them. Add in the rise in employer National Insurance and every hire, right or wrong, now costs more to carry.
The salary is the main part you can see.
Where the cost of a bad hire actually comes from
When a hire doesn’t work out, the money leaks out in places that rarely show up on one spreadsheet.
The salary paid while they settle in and while you wait to see if it works out.
The onboarding and training time, from you and your team.
The manager hours spent coaching, covering and eventually managing them out.
The targets missed, the deals that slipped and the customers who noticed.
The rest of the team picking up the slack and sometimes deciding to leave.
Then doing the whole hire again, usually under more pressure than the first time.
That last one is the sting. A rushed rehire can often result in the next bad hire.
The empty seat costs money too
The cost of the vacancy gets talked about even less.
Every commercial role exists for a reason and it’s usually a revenue reason. When that seat is empty, the work either doesn’t happen or lands on someone who already has a full day.
Here’s a simple way to work out your own figure.
Take what the role is expected to bring in or protect each month. Multiply it by the number of months it’s likely to sit empty. Then add the time your team spends covering it.
Picture an account executive expected to bring in £25,000 of new business a month once they’re up and running. If that role takes four months to fill, that’s £100,000 of revenue that doesn’t happen. That’s before anyone counts the hours the sales manager spent covering the patch and sitting in interviews.
Suddenly a recruitment fee and speed to hire look more appealing.
Speed or getting it right?
This is where the two costs pull against each other. Move too slowly and the empty seat gets expensive. Move too quickly and you risk paying for a bad hire instead.
The answer isn’t choosing one. It’s doing the work early, so you can move quickly without cutting corners.
How to avoid paying twice
A few things I’ve seen make the biggest difference.
Start with the commercial goal. Know what this person needs to achieve in their first twelve months before you write the job description. It sharpens the brief and makes the right person much easier to spot.
Check your package offering is up to date before you go to market. If your salary or benefits have drifted, you’ll struggle to attract candidates or find out halfway through a process when your preferred candidate accepts another offer. Far better to know at the start.
Bring your recruitment partner in early. The fastest hires I’ve made were for businesses I already knew well. When a role was signed off, there was no lengthy briefing or starting from scratch. I knew the market, I knew who to call and the right people were in conversation within days.
Hire for values as well as skills. Skills can be built. Someone who doesn’t share how your business works rarely settles, however strong the CV. That’s why Alento screens against your values as part of our process.
Be honest with candidates. Tell them what the role really involves, the good bits and the harder ones. People who join with their eyes open tend to stay.
Keep the process streamlined. Agree the stages and the timeline up front, then stick to them. Good candidates don’t wait around.
No process removes risk completely. People are people and on occasion a hire that looked right on every measure just doesn’t work out.
But most bad hires don’t come out of nowhere. They usually come from a rushed brief, a stretched team and a role that’s been empty for too long. Fix those and the odds shift a long way in your favour.
If an empty seat is starting to cost you more than you’d like, get in touch. We’re happy to help.
FAQs
How much does a bad hire cost in the UK?
There’s no single official figure, as it depends on the role, the seniority and how quickly the problem is spotted. One recent survey of UK business leaders estimated a mis-hire costs a typical business around £125,000.
What is the cost of vacancy?
It’s the value a business loses while a role sits empty: missed revenue, delayed projects and extra workload for the rest of the team.
How do you calculate the cost of an unfilled position?
Estimate the monthly revenue or value the role delivers, multiply it by the number of months it’s likely to stay empty, then add the time your team spends covering it.
How can you reduce the risk of a bad hire?
Start with a clear commercial goal for the role, check your offer against the market, hire for values as well as skills and keep the process tight so strong candidates don’t drop out.


